I would think if you are in the pulpit of a church you would want to speak a.) PDF The Perfect You Download a one-page info sheet about Dr. Of course you do you must. This is DECEPTION! I also know that it only makes one an expert in one very small slice of knowledge. Question everything, hold on to the good. Its certainly a unique window into the human psyche that one doesnt tend to see in other parts of life, so in some ways its a privilege to be sledged as I am from time to time. But, there is good news. Your email address will not be published. And we need to always check what we hear, especially from the pulpit. In other words, she has no degree or credentials to qualify as such yet this is what she lectures on (Masters in Speech Therapy and Phd in Communication Pathology). Our past, present and future is already done for us. The plans of our sovereign Lord rarely align with our plans, and if we proceed as though they are we will end up off course. Verse 2 in the NLV version is especially interesting. Actually, Dr Leaf is trained as a communication pathologist. We believe that with a little bit of deeper probing,Dr Leaf's claims and hypotheses aren't as strong as they appear. You can read the introduction to my book on Dr Leaf here: http://www.debunkingdrleaf.com/new-page it is a more in-depth discussion on my work and its context. She developed her theory (called the Geodesic Information Processing theory) of how we think, build memory, and learn, into tools and processes that have transformed the lives of hundreds of thousands of individuals with Traumatic . When considered in the historical and global context [2], most of human illness is related to preventable diseases that are so rare in the modern western world because of generations of high quality public health and medical care. All ideas need critiquing. Also, heres a link to 100 verses about how no one is perfect. 1:7). 10. Youre welcome to your opinion John. Next time you see your physic in Melbourne, let them know why you didnt download Dr Leafs app. I follow Dr.Leaf on ger socials and something seemed to bother my conscience as to why she has changed the tune of her inspirational quotes making it less God-focused and more self-centric. Hes brilliant, so were brilliant because were made in his image. I do not believe we are brilliant, but disciples in learning mode, like sheep who at times go astray. To reiterate, I am not frustrated with the Lifegroup, and I think _____________ Church has an excellent and balanced ministry. The scripture is clear on this: You do not have a spirit of fear but of love, power and a sound mind (2 Tim 1:7)., Simply checking the verse in its full context, and in a different translation, shows it in a completely different light to the way Dr Leaf promotes it. Caroline Leaf shows that her program of taking wrong thoughts and replacing them with truth will physically erase that thought or memoryand its associated emotionsin the brain and will change the physical structure of the brain to accommodate the true replacement thought and emotion. How to Have Joy in Your Golden Years Despite These 10 Life California - Do Not Sell My Personal Information. When we were born, most of us came out of the womb, and into this world, head first. And we all know how that story ended. For example, on the 12th of May 2014, she posted to her social media feeds, Your mind is all-powerful. She would speak some psychological concepts occasionally that sounded like they came from Psych 101. It was not a few words interpreted differently, but the entire presentation. About Christ and our need for him I hope youre out of your cloud of depression, or are almost there, and I wish you all the best for your journey of understanding into psychology. When we begin to think toxic thoughts, proteins will begin to grow on the dendrites. For this reason I remind you to fan into flame the gift of God, which is in you through the laying on of my hands. I am happy to drop the issue, as I have said everything, do not feel I have more to say on it and am satisfied with your reply. Dr Caroline Leaf - Still Contradicted by the Latest Evidence, Scripture In this devotional based on her bestselling book, Dr. Caroline Leaf combines current scientific research with biblical teaching to help readers understand the power of their thoughts and how to transform their minds. Healing Begins With Sanctification Discerning the World Well Ill conclude by offering a piece of worldly advice life is fleeting. She is one of the most renowned authors and speakers in the western Christian world. These are for personal use only. Would you mind telling us why you wrote the book? Since the early 1980's she has studied and researched the Mind-Brain connection. The data will be used to identify needs and priorities, benchmark against various population characteristics, evaluate programs and policies, plan for services and programs, and advocate for resources. And 1 Thessalonians 5:21 says, test everything; hold on to the good. Leaf is teaching at least something of merit that will help people regain control of their egos, take ownership for their behaviours and hopefully lead them closer to God. Your article and responses to such a variety of readers has been inspiring and thought provoking. 2008 by Switch On Your Brain Intl. Any and all express or implied warranties, including the warranties of merchantability and fitness for a particular purpose, are disclaimed. Globally, mental health concerns are growing. In this revolutionary book, Dr. Caroline Leaf packs an incredible amount of information that will change readers' eating and thinking habits for the better. I will add that today was day six of my wife not taking her meds, and we spent the day figuring out how to get her back on them, as she is now experiencing the consequence of six days without meds. Construct validity with blood measures also revealed significant relationships between the toxic stress and anxiety subscale and homocysteine levels and DHEA/cortisol ratios. They stop sharing their opinions because they get ignored or ostracised. I might add, Dr Leafs insistence that shes a cognitive neuroscientist and an expert on mental health and nutrition is also quite insulting for real psychologists, neuroscientists and nutritionists whose opinions are ignored in favour of a self-titled expert whose only authority comes by popular demand, not training or experience. Hi TM, regarding your comments regarding evidence, the book and every blog Ive written has always been fully referenced. Switch On Your Brain with the 5-Step Learning Process, http://drleaf.com/download-dispatch/?fn=/Web-page-AA-research-project-3.pdf, http://drleaf.com/assets/files/DrCarolineLeaf_CurriculumVitae1.pdf. No one is perfectly congruent in everything they say. The Apostle Paul said in Romans 12:2 that we are transformed by the renewing of the mind. These findings show that the NeurocycleTM has an impact on mental health from a whole-brain perspective. The explanation is that this verse has nothing to do with our thought life at all. You say, I still cannot understand what drives you to want to pick apart Carolines work. PLoS medicine 2010;7(11):e1000361. And, if we detox our thoughts, we will be restored to the health that God intended. We can, however, become a part of the healing process by thinking about, whatever is true, whatever is noble, whatever is right, whatever is pure, whatever is lovely, whatever is admirableif anything is excellent or praiseworthythink about such things. (Philippians 4:8). Any use of this information is at the users discretion. Thank you so much for your time, and I hope youre staying well! I now clearly see why you have written your book. Feel free to share your experiences in the comments section. Leaf is currently conducting clinical trials using the5-step program she developed while in private practice to further demonstrate the effectiveness of mind-directed techniques to help relieve mental ill-health problems such as anxiety, depression and intrusive thoughts. Note that you must not take shortcuts. The Greek word for fear in this scripture refers to timidity, fearfulness, cowardice, not to anxiety or terror. Here are my thoughts on the messages from Dr. Carolyn Leaf, which I have now listened to twice (all four presentations). Is that necessary or indeed emblematic of what academic critiquing is? I can understand and appreciate your feelings and concerns based on your familys health history. Leaf has given these growths 3 different names, depending upon the size & shape: bump, lollipop and mushroom. God is not trying to teach us through sickness. As Jesus suffered, so anyone who wants to follow Him will also suffer. your brain will convince you that your brain can be renewed by the power of god s spirit and biblical truth When you recall a toxic thought created by a trauma, that thought contains both information and emotion. Im willing to engage in robust discussion especially when people are overtly hostile, and allow me to pre-emptively state that youre welcome to your opinion on that too. While I have been reading her book switch on your brain I did get quite excited about the possibility that the answer was so easy but I also had the check in my spirit or maybe just years of dads words in my ears if it sounds too good/too easy to be true then youre probably right. Pray: What a powerful statement that I can say, I am a child of God, chosen before this world was created to do good works for Gods kingdom. [1: p33,38]. Well done on making the time to share an alternative perspective. Please take the time to tell outline your concerns about Dr Leaf to your friends, social media followers, and the pastors of the church you saw her at. That bothered me a lot, but I ignored it cause I was getting myself back on track. Thanks for sharing your opinion. Switch On Your Brain Workbook : The Key to Peak Happiness, Thinking What I heard troubled me, and I blogged about my concerns to open a dialogue on Dr Leaf and her teaching. Okay thank you for posting a different view on this subject. In reality, modern medicine and civil engineering, not our thought life, have everything to do with our good health.. She frequently lectures toaudiences worldwide, linking scientific principles of the brain to spiritual, intellectual and emotional issues in simple and practical ways. KCM Broadcast Notes April 17-21 2023 - The Christian Chain of Command. Thanks for your comment. As if thats not bad enough, Dr Leaf also cites biased sources, pseudoscientists, and other sources that directly contradict her assertion [7; Ch 10]. Toxic thoughts can lead to all sorts of different health problems including mental health and even dementia. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. But where did you mention the evidence for your arguments against her? Ive had just as many people comment that my tone has been very respectful. The 1st 21 days were effective even thought some things were questionable. So instead of trying to pull each other down, lets see how we can at least highlight what we do agree with and share that message with our brethren. I was hoping to read the bibliographies. So now I have completed more than the 63 days. ""Dr Leaf is a global Christian phenomenon, endorsed by some of Christianitys most famous leaders. She has endorsements from Joyce Meyer, Bobbie Houston, and a number of other pre-eminent Christian pastors. Perhaps you do not know her world view or what she has read or not. Her influence continues to grow. I realize that Dr. Carolyn Leaf did not suggest anyone just go cold turkey off their meds, but we did not hear Dr. Carolyn Leaf last weekend. Since the early 1980's she has studied and researched the Mind-Brain connection. You clearly didnt read the book or any of my blogs as if you had, you would see the scientific evidence that I referenced in support of my position. Its really good for us to consider all views prayerfully before making up our minds. Since 1981, Dr. Caroline Leaf has researched the human brain with particular emphasis on unlocking its vast, untapped potential. DAY 8: Track Your Progress by Moms Letting Go Without Giving Up This, in itself is delightful and, intriguing because, as you work out your gift and find out who you are, you will be developing your soul and spirit. (Emphasis added), This quote in and of itself isnt actually that significant until we compare it to a quote from the first chapter of Dr Leafs 2013 book, Switch on your brain. [1], The first argument proposes that thoughts come from your brain as though your brain is generating all aspects of your mental experience. Dare I ask you do you know the difference between academic critiquing and vexatious criticisim? Heather Riggleman is a believer, wife, mom, author, social media consultant, and full-time writer. This is interesting: http://www.abideinchrist.com/messages/2cor3v18.html. Teacher Mindfulness Training using the NeurocycleTM. Since speaking at C3 Every Women's Conference, we have been following the quackademic Caroline Leaf on Church Watch. (This is explained in more detail, and with the appropriate references, in my book [7]). In our superposition with God, we are in a position to collect a probability which has not happened in our lives into an actuality. In our superposition, we need to be glad not in our works, but that our names are written in the lambs book of life and that we are being saved, and will be saved. Dr. Leaf's "Perfect You" philosophy builds on the wisdom of past generations of sound, experienced thinkers and boasts the utmost spiritual, scriptural, and scientific validation. Again, I have had a number of people recount their issues with Dr Leaf and her teaching people with very legitimate mental illnesses who have been directly affected by following Dr Leafs advice, or indirectly affected because their church has been convinced by Dr Leafs teaching that mental illness is the result of toxic thinking, and as a result, failed to give appropriate support to those who are the most vulnerable and most in need of support. Anyway, I really must get on. You state that you have not seen anything written to back up my arguments, but you only need to look at the bottom of every blog post and the last chapter of the book and see the list of citations. When the lies in my life get loud, I will listen for your voice instead. Joyce Meyer for example teaches that positive affirmations change or impact reality, denying Gods sovereignty or giving us creating power equal to God?? and biblical insight, Dr. Caroline Leaf empowers readers to take control of their thoughts in order to take control of their lives. Dr Caroline Leaf | SpiritMindBody Connection I shouldnt have spoken out of emotion and without informing myself properly. Home Uncategorized Chris Rosebrough exposes the gnostic Manichean heresy of Dr Caroline Leaf, By churchwatcher on January 7, 2015 ( 1 ). [6] Ronsmans C, Graham WJ, Lancet Maternal Survival Series steering g. Maternal mortality: who, when, where, and why. We must be vigilant! I like the reference to Stephen in Acts 6, which I am sure would not have been a good example for Carolyn to use because by her definition, Stephen may have been thinking incorrectly and suffering as a result of it. It would be much easier just to give my personal opinion. While many in the church adorn themselves with her teaching, a growing minority are starting to realise that the Emperor has no clothes. Just google Caroline Leaf criticism and in amongst my posts, youll also find a number of other reviews. That Dr Leaf also regularly misquotes her sources and relies on unpublished opinion from pseudoscientists and new-age practitioners also brings her reputation as an expert scientist into disrepute. I always find it interesting how people seem to conflate objective truth with subjective opinion. In fact, you cannot be categorized! Each communication contains a URL that participants use to gain access to the survey. If you have a medical matter or emergency, please contact a local medical professional immediately. Switch On Your Brain Every Day: 365 Readings for Peak Happiness You were right to challenge me when you thought I wasnt being forthcoming. From our perspective, it is not yet done. God gave us a brain, its appropriate that we actually use it. It is a very insightful review. Without critique, how do Christians see both sides of an argument and make up their own minds? Leaf has published a number of articles in academic journals and consumer magazines, and has been widely interviewed in newspapers, on radio and on television shows about her research and theories. After attaining her foundational education in the neuroscience of communication pathology, Dr. These results strengthen existing research that has established the same relationships. Switch On Your Brain : The Key to Peak Happiness, Thinking, and Health. She is a former award-winning journalist with over 2,000 articles published. Be a servant of Love! NOTE: This is NOT a substitute. It had bad reviews so I was looking for more information on her. Her husband, Mr Mac Leaf, dismissed my concerns out of hand, which only steeled me to take further action. Dr. Leaf trained educators and therapists on classroom-based intervention for learning and mental health management that impacted the lives of thousands of students and teachers. She uses this little factoid all the time to justify her belief in the power of thoughts. Many mental health problems can be reversed by eliminating toxic thoughts and rewiring the brain. When we hope, it is an activity of the mind that changes the structure of our brain in a positive and normal direction. Write letters to the leaders of your denomination. The World Health Organization (2022) has reported that there was a 13% rise in mental health conditions and substance abuse disorders from 2007 to 2017. Please, just tell me if River Valley Church is a name it and claim it organization, and we can save a lot of time! In the end, the Emperor was duped so badly that he paraded in front of all his subjects au naturel, but Nobody would confess that he couldnt see anything, for that would prove him either unfit for his position, or a fool. The enemy is cunning and shrewd. Dr Leafs teachings are not supported by science, nor by scripture. And lastly, people wouldnt be mentally ill and dying 15-25 years earlier now verses 60 years ago, if we just adjusted our lifestyle choices by 1)eating 2) sleeping 3) exercising No one has yet done that for Dr Leaf.2. 1. In addition, theyare currently in data collection of a longitudinal national study of the Neurocycleprogram users, and planning some upcoming work with teachers, parents and children, all of which they will publish in peer-reviewed journals as soon as they are complete. Now, two years of intense research, dozens of posts and a book later, people are starting to take notice. I have just started reading Switch on your brain but it bothered me greatly when I saw Joyce Meyer endorsed it. On and on, the same pattern continues. This Diatribe is so lengthy, youve worked very hard to convince yourself of something other than the truth. It certainly doesnt say that our minds are more powerful and effective than any medication, any threat, any sickness, or any neurological challenge. Switch On Your Brain, LLC and the author specifically disclaim any and all liability arising directly or indirectly from the use or application of any information contained in these materials. Her work deserves interrogation and analysis like any other scientific work. Also, please understand that just because I dont support this kind of theology, does not mean I dont support the idea of the fact that God can heal in His time. Chris Rosebrough exposes the gnostic Manichean heresy of "Dr" Caroline Leaf By churchwatcher on January 7, 2015 ( 1). First, you have to gather awareness. According to the Pulpit commentary found on the Bible Hub website, The verb here used is (shaar), to estimate to calculate, and the clause is best rendered, For as one that calculates with himself, so is he. QEEG measurements of 11 NeurocycleTM participants were performed before using the NeurocycleTM, after the first 21 days, and after the final 63 days to assess mental health improvements. I can tell you are frustrated with what happened at Lifegroups and have issue with what Dr. Caroline taught. In her 2009 book, The gift in you [12], Dr Leaf teaches about the gifts that we have, specifically, our gifts are something uniquely hardwired into our brain, something that we cannot change even if we wanted to, and that its our brain structure that gives rise to the way in which we think, the actions that we take, and the gifts we are given from God. If you support Dr Leafs ministry of false hope, then thats your call. Leaf also says,As we think, we change the physical nature of our brain. Their condemnation has long been hanging over them, and their destruction has not been sleeping. (2 Peter 2:1-3). John Paul Jacksons False Prophecy Thank you very much for explaining to me further. In their greed these teachers will exploit you with fabricated stories. Carl Laferton Carlos R Messerli Carol Dunker Carole Mayhall Carolina Johnasson Carolina Welin Caroline Leaf Carter Lindberg Catalina Echeverri Catharina J M Halkes Catherine Bishop Catherine . Participants feedback revealed that the program made it easy to apply their learning in their work and school lives, and that they desired further future mindfulness trainings via this program structure. (Accessed 08/01/2014.). Throughout this time, Dr. Dr Leaf can spruik whatever she likes, but her claims of expertise and her scientific and scriptural legitimacy are crumbling. Our pastors and leaders vouch for Dr Leafs teaching because its been endorsed by world-renowned Christian leaders like Kenneth Copeland and Joyce Meyer. Their mindfulness development and mental health were assessed by the Leaf Mind Management (LMM) scale before and after the program. Data is analyzed by an independent research and analysis consulting firm, Elite Research, LLC (www.eliteresearch.com). We will all be judged for what we teach or allow to be taught in our sphere of influence about the things of God, so never mind my email. She is also a self-titled theologian. Miraculous Brain - With David Rives and Dr. Caroline Leaf on TBN The others (2 25%) come from exposure to chemicals in food, etc. This suggests a topic called Mind (or Religious) Science, basically suggesting that man can control his own destiny. Just like it originally took 21 days for the mushroom to develop, expect it to take at least 21 days to reverse it. She has found a niche, pretending to be a scientist in a closed community of mostly non-scientists who simply accept what she teaches because of the platform given to her from people who should be more discerning and apply due process to the information allowed from their pulpits. Beyond that, there really isnt a lot that Dr Leaf says thats truly beneficial, and its suffocated by the weight of mistruth that remains in her message. This is part of the Jeremiah 17:9 problem. Reblogged this on my open book and commented: And hey, its your opinion youre welcome to it. All the churches and Christians, myself being one, have swallowed her hook, line, and sinker.
Dear Harriette Uexpress, Lucky Luciano Ring, Articles I